Press "Enter" to skip to content

Former Rudy Giuliani Aide: He’s Now ‘A Right-Wing Conspiracy Nut’ | The Beat With Ari Melber | MSNBC


100 Comments

  1. Jacqueline Wernett
    Jacqueline Wernett October 9, 2019

    Rudy stuck his head in a toilet…Christine Todd Whitman never did…I grew up in Cherry Hill after Hamburg…Sally Starr taught me English with her kids show…L'chaim and happy Yom Kippur…

  2. Janice L
    Janice L October 9, 2019

    A COUP, Attempt Against The People's Sitting President…By The "D" Party And The Elites NWO…With MSM Pushing The Agenda Of The Elites NWO..They Want To Remove The Right To Freedom Of Speech, So That All You Are Brain Washed To Hear Is The Agenda Of The NWO…Which Is….Agenda 21 now Agenda 30….And The Georgia Guide Stone's Agenda to "Depopulation"…….They Don't want you to know they think Of the People's As Usless Eaters, Taking Up What They See As Their Space…The Elites NWO For The People's..!!!!🙈🙊🙉👺👺👺👺💩👹☠️

  3. Vee Cee
    Vee Cee October 9, 2019

    Christine Todd Whitman is the sort of Republican who, unfortunately, is missing in today's GOP. A woman of intelligence and integrity, and someone I could vote for, even though I am a Democrat. I used to vote for the candidate, not the party, crossing over party lines if I thought the Republicans had the better candidate. But I will NEVER vote for another Republican as long as these thugs are in office.

  4. Steve Moyer
    Steve Moyer October 9, 2019

    Didn't he do the same thing about the twin towers wreckage?

  5. Steve Moyer
    Steve Moyer October 9, 2019

    To bad I was only 11 back then when that happened

  6. UC Vibes
    UC Vibes October 9, 2019

    Secratary of State Hillary Clinton testified to congress under oath. Why can't the corrupt Trump administration face testifying under oath?

  7. Steve Moyer
    Steve Moyer October 9, 2019

    Just know when Trump said "I'm Fcked" yup that was me

  8. Tenly2009
    Tenly2009 October 9, 2019

    If Congress continues to be so impotent, they should be disbanded. Use the money saved to do something for the American people.
    They have been worse than useless for the past 2 years and are disgracing the country and the constitution with their inaction and failure to punish those who ignore or refuse lawfully issued subpoenas. Their job is to protect the country from corruption and incompetence in the executive branch and they are obviously unwilling to do so unless they can think they can do it in a manner that benefits them politically.
    I wish we could fire all of them and start over. The entire system is broken and needs a significant overhaul with a focus on eliminating corruption.

  9. Joe Weis
    Joe Weis October 9, 2019

    Crooked Nixon ! Crooked Trump !

  10. LONE WOLF
    LONE WOLF October 9, 2019

    GIULIANI ALWAYS LOOKS LIKE HE'S DOING THE OINK OINK SCENE FROM THE MOVIE DELIVERANCE 😂😂😂😂😂

  11. Digdog
    Digdog October 9, 2019

    This is where morons get together

  12. Haitian Refugee
    Haitian Refugee October 9, 2019

    When the security apparatus is used for political purposes the country will split & civil war will ensue. Liberals & conservatives should realize this.

  13. NewtonDynamics
    NewtonDynamics October 9, 2019

    Rudy Giulliany is the Heel of the White house. Trump needs him in order to make him not sound like the Joker.

  14. Tre Bucketz
    Tre Bucketz October 9, 2019

    Rudy is a dead ringer for Col. Klink (someone give him a monocle). Which makes Pompeo, Shultz….. "Her Komandant, I know nutting"!

  15. Gordon Hislop
    Gordon Hislop October 9, 2019

    I think Rudy is doing a great job and I fail to see where he has lied about anything. A fact that you are all about to face.

  16. Senna458
    Senna458 October 9, 2019

    I'm sure that the next time a drug dealer (or a mob boss arranging a hit) is captured on tape making a deal, he'll easily be able to defend himself by saying "I was just joking. Did you honestly think that I was serious?"

  17. Matthew Bowen
    Matthew Bowen October 9, 2019

    The Chinese thought he was serious they ask for clarity within hours of his public comments.

  18. al spencer
    al spencer October 9, 2019

    There nothing but devils walking amongst us!

  19. al spencer
    al spencer October 9, 2019

    The wrong part about all of this is the right people aren’t doing anything about the wrong people, there’s no consequences for their actions that’s why they keep doing what they’re doing.

  20. Lance Charles
    Lance Charles October 9, 2019

    Because he was a key player on 911. Bush black water inside job. Giuliani knows where all the skeletons are buried.

  21. nick world
    nick world October 9, 2019

    I love that ppl are mad because Rudy is a badass lawyer and all you fools are just jealous hes not on your side.

  22. Roland M
    Roland M October 9, 2019

    Nobody believes MSNBC anymore totally anti-American

  23. Bryant Saunders
    Bryant Saunders October 9, 2019

    No, you cadre of GOD-LESS deviants!!! Relax.. count backward or something!!!! The E.U and the Dem attempt has FAILED!! YOU LOST!!! YOU'LL LOSE AGAIN!!! AND AGAIN!!! AND AGAIN!!!

  24. Howie Hannigan
    Howie Hannigan October 9, 2019

    Haha he's digging up all your friends lies and crimes. Enjoy mshiv👌😂

  25. felix ortega
    felix ortega October 9, 2019

    Its sad to see what this forma great Mayor of NYC has become…so sad

  26. Z Lister
    Z Lister October 9, 2019

    MSNBC is fake news. This is awful. They're just praying on people's hate of trump. And hoping to God don't really listen to what they're saying

  27. Nuke Canada
    Nuke Canada October 9, 2019

    Lawyers don't lie. I've heard everything now!

  28. lord fly
    lord fly October 9, 2019

    (The GOP) won't allow the evidence to come out, then crys we have no evidense to judge?

    How can we judge, crys republicans.

    This is Ostrich syndrome.

    You can't stick your head any deeper in the sand than republicans have them now.

  29. 8alot4t
    8alot4t October 9, 2019

    Hypocracy united – shame on these unpatriotic politicians

  30. Johnny Petty
    Johnny Petty October 9, 2019

    MSNBC: Mostly S#@*, No Believable Content. It is amazing how everything the Republicans bring out is a conspiracy. Even when the Democratic theories fall flat or their action constitute obvious crimes, this network backs them.

  31. Luz Fernandez
    Luz Fernandez October 9, 2019

    Jajajajajajajajajajajajajajajajajajajajajajajajaj FAKE NEWS
    TRUMP TRUMP TRUMP TRUMP TRUMP TRUMP TRUMP TRUMP TRUMP TRUMP TRUMP 2020♥️

  32. Vicky Jameus
    Vicky Jameus October 9, 2019

    Republicans are lawyer's now 😲 what's next

  33. Dale Gervais
    Dale Gervais October 9, 2019

    Deamoncrats are the “Do nothing “ but hate and hoax party. deamoncrats are the humiliation of the world.

  34. Gwynne D'Amico
    Gwynne D'Amico October 9, 2019

    Sounds to me like he's been drinking Trump's Koolaid!!!

  35. Osunga Okello
    Osunga Okello October 9, 2019

    There is : (1) "Do you think he was serious" , meaning did he mean for China to do that, and (2) There is :"Do you think he is serious" , meaning would China actually do that? Mostly people focus on the intent , which is (1) , and whethe it was "intended" for a particular result. But, (2) is the result of the intended or unintended request is also imminent? In general that's the whole point of being powerful, isn't it? That when you say "jump" people everywhere say "how high?" They don't decide that you're joking first. Maybe they might, after jumping, but not before. …. Or, Welcome to the world's ultimate alternate universe >> A paid experience available now, try it for FREE, paste this into your browser, and remove all spaces. Enjoy! >> w w w . b o o om . c o m / 2 . html "Honk Kong Snowden."

  36. Greg Gentile
    Greg Gentile October 9, 2019

    Rudy rocks!

  37. Tribble Booth
    Tribble Booth October 9, 2019

    Looking at the early footage of Giuliani wearing a wig, proves that he's got a sense of humour.

  38. Mikael Funch
    Mikael Funch October 9, 2019

    A female republican I will listen to……rare….. Thanks

  39. rex LARSEN
    rex LARSEN October 9, 2019

    corrupt biden is fair game .. 😀

  40. MrRosiesfavorites
    MrRosiesfavorites October 9, 2019

    all you have to do is look back on what Moscow mitch did in the senate to push thru those rt wing judges. he is corrupt and this impeachment will fail in the senate because he is corrupt. trump will again be elected just like Nixon was. the red party voters are totally gullible when it comes to the promises made by their chosen ones.

  41. Otto Nicator
    Otto Nicator October 9, 2019

    Trump has not done a thing, other than recreate acts of past presidents, while enriching his pockets…..

    America is corrupt and these people deserve to be punished, by death………

  42. Dale Gervais
    Dale Gervais October 9, 2019

    This is how deamoncrats hoax elections and and how they hoaxed the 2007/8 economic collapse to appoint the fascist Iranian/Russian oblama. Oblama explained to the Russians that biden and him would do more after the upcoming fake re-appointment of his cop killing failed ethnic cleansing and child caging presidential hoax.

  43. Dale Gervais
    Dale Gervais October 9, 2019

    your a hate and hoax epstein pedo deamoncrat child caging liar. It is that simple.

  44. uncle ho
    uncle ho October 9, 2019

    Does this narrative really convince you folks? C'mon, people, start putting one and one together. It's not that hard. It's been three years of this… 🙂 endless hyperbole, spin, propaganda. When will you wake up to the reality that you've been duped?

  45. jesushatesyoutoo
    jesushatesyoutoo October 9, 2019

    I think Rudy went after the mob back in the day because he wanted their turf.

  46. Gilbert Ramirez
    Gilbert Ramirez October 9, 2019

    I don't get it, this impeachment inquiry is to acquire more information, sounds like another Witch Hunt part 2. Oh boy…

  47. Otto Nicator
    Otto Nicator October 9, 2019

    666 to the United States Gov and to everyone elected and holds office…

    Most of them, are too busy doing drugs, to be bothered with doing their job…. Trump is an example of this, he showed up to the victims of those storms, higher than a kite, saying stupid crap, like he did at the UN, he is a POS.. America is a very sick psychologically and behaviorally. The behavior exhibited it completely unacceptable for a Governing Nation, especially given the influence America has.. I seriously believe they are so bad, they need to be made an example of, if that means war, then so be it…. But their murdering leaders, civilians, not to mention the fact that they are so corrupt, it needs to end…

    Trump should be publically executed. As should have Obama, Bush, Clinton, Bush, Reagan, Carter, etc.. and the list goes on and on..

  48. Andy Macedo
    Andy Macedo October 9, 2019

    Don wants an apology from the whistle blower ? That's ridiculous ! He honestly doesn't understand English ? The law clearly states that it's supposed to be on the down low and incognito – that's unspeakable ! I just can't believe someone is president that can't speak or understand English ! Gibberish is not a real life language can't just go around speaking gibberish to everyone and calling everything a hoax or witch hunt ! That's ridiculous – where's my bae ? My girlfriend ? I'm surprised she's still putting up with all this nonsense ? It's like listening to a foreign language and not being able to comprehend anything ! I don't see much of a point to keep listening ? Who knows what good that would do for anyone things are just unacceptable ! Gone fishing is not an acceptable response to Turkish forces crossing the border ! Can't wipe out terrorists without wiping out the Kurds first that's unspeakable ! I think someone should start paying attention !!!!!' Things ain't okay the way there unfolding ! Impeachment isn't a voluntary thing it's a way to hold the executive office accountable ! It's also in that document that is called the constitution – the thing being used as target practice on the range and being ignored ! I just don't think that trending now should have anything other that the constitution or democracy ! Everything is in peril and up in the air a crisis ! Look at the video of everyone fleeing the area whose watching the prisoners and ISIS ???? Nobody is there gonna be running amok again ! Unspeakable !

  49. Abelardo Solo
    Abelardo Solo October 9, 2019

    Give the senates jobs to the immigrants because none of you Americans wants to do your jobs.

  50. Dale Gervais
    Dale Gervais October 9, 2019

    Trump saved us from oblama/deamoncrat hate and divide politics. Oblama destroyed our medical , our police officers, our economy, our jobs, our FBI and supported Iranian terrorism, plantation hate politics, and epstein pedophile politics. Then he pardoned 1715 violent felons and caged children. He is the most hated president alive today.

  51. Kim Bradbury
    Kim Bradbury October 9, 2019

    More fake news.

  52. Robin Fleet
    Robin Fleet October 9, 2019

    When you lie to me every day and lie about the little things, inconsequential things, I can have no confidence in you. I will hear you speak, I will hear the words you say and the sentiment you are trying to present, but I will not believe you and will wait for corroboration before accepting what you said. If you can govern in that environment then good luck, you will be too slow to act and delayed in learning critical information to inform decisions. No officer of the federal government should, at this point in time, feel safe in executing a directive from this administration. There is no reason to believe that the directive is legal, made in good faith or even has the support of the issuer of the directive and should be acted on only after corroboration is made from more neutral third parties. Welcome to a second layer of federal bureaucracy just to fact check and verify the administration.

  53. Richard Conner
    Richard Conner October 9, 2019

    RUDY,S BROKE,TRUMP'S GONNA CUT HIM A NICE CHECK TO PLAY HIS STOOGE…SOME PEOPLE GOT NO SCRUPLES.

  54. Jorge de Arca
    Jorge de Arca October 9, 2019

    TRUMP 2020 BISHEEEZ…. 😀

  55. sun dial
    sun dial October 9, 2019

    MSNBC IS A LEFT WING CONSPIRACY NUTCASES 😄

  56. John Doe
    John Doe October 9, 2019

    HaHa, you dems don't like the truth! It's coming back to haunt you! Hahaha!!!

  57. randall stevens
    randall stevens October 9, 2019

    The new Rudy and the old Rudy are the same ask ex-wife Donna Hanover! She was blindsided when Rudy announced his divorce from her by way of the local news! Also when he was running for mayor he participated with an unruly mob destroying property police storming barricades against the then Mayor Dinkins!! It’s all easy to find by google and YouTube!

  58. Lissybird
    Lissybird October 9, 2019

    Rudys rude. He’s becoming a Jerry Springer of politics.
    He should go away now.

  59. Russell Newton
    Russell Newton October 9, 2019

    A very clever man, he’s manipulated 40% of the electorate to believe him, amazing.

  60. Russell Newton
    Russell Newton October 9, 2019

    As a outsider, out of all the media I have seen, cnn, msnbc, pbc , Ari Melber seems to play it down the middle in a fair manner.

  61. Officer Zigler
    Officer Zigler October 9, 2019

    Alt left tinfoil hat conspiracy theorists in the safe space echo chamber. CNN has been wrong every time since 2016. Highly educated intelligent Alt left soy latte sipping propaganda cult members have no talking points, no debate since 2016. ME ME MEME NPC University pretty well sums it up.

  62. Nora
    Nora October 9, 2019

    how far he has fallen. Sad really.

  63. Adam Howard
    Adam Howard October 9, 2019

    Whatever Putin has on our President has to be damming to have Trump continually be so acquiescent.

  64. Frank San Nicolas
    Frank San Nicolas October 9, 2019

    The guy that took down the mob lived long enough to become a villain.

  65. # hamdale
    # hamdale October 9, 2019

    I posed a question to my friends and family during the presidential campaigns, 'how would we handle a president that's an obvious liar?' We're seeing the answer play out daily.

  66. ZenCoder
    ZenCoder October 9, 2019

    TRE45ON

  67. OG1 SHINOBI
    OG1 SHINOBI October 10, 2019

    Young rudy julian juliani looks like robocop without the mask

  68. Shaun McDaniel
    Shaun McDaniel October 10, 2019

    THIS from a channel that has had one conspiracy theory after another against Trump, EVEN calling him a "quote Russian agent" at one point. MSNBC, Hypocrisy much?

  69. daddy hoes
    daddy hoes October 10, 2019

    A bunch of old crazy white folks running a country scary

  70. K Comm
    K Comm October 10, 2019

    CAN I SPEAK THE ABSOLUTE TRUTH HERE??? HIS FOLLOWERS DO NOT CARE….AND GET MORE EMBOLDENED WITH STUFF LIKE THIS.

  71. Antonio Sciorra
    Antonio Sciorra October 10, 2019

    As a former New Yorker, we warned you all what low life creeps these two were. Trump is a bitter failure in anything he touches. Giuliani wanted to be king of New York long before the 9-11-photo-op Mayor Giuliani that the average American thinks they know. Giuliani bankrupted NYC with all the overtime that he gifted to NYPD to fight "Quality of Life" crimes like jailing non-white folks via Rockefeller laws.

  72. Aggie Vulaj
    Aggie Vulaj October 10, 2019

    Our government due to Trump & Republicans is a side show. A disgrace!

  73. intuitknit
    intuitknit October 10, 2019

    Why isn't the public protesting???? Forget about the politicians who are obviously compromised. The people need to stand up and go public in masses.

  74. dart arkana
    dart arkana October 10, 2019

    Rudy Giuliani is 2 drinks away from chasing knoames out of his lawn for illegal immigration

  75. Joe Morales
    Joe Morales October 10, 2019

    THIS EPA TROLL LIED ABOUT 9/11 HEALTH HAZARDS

  76. Gary Schultz
    Gary Schultz October 10, 2019

    Rudy is in it too deep, he has past the point of No return, there is No out for him now.
    He bet on Trump, He has lost everything.

  77. who dat ?
    who dat ? October 10, 2019

    still wont change a Trump 2020 landslide win

  78. Dale Gervais
    Dale Gervais October 10, 2019

    Trump 2020. Biden/oblama/clinton/pelosi will be investigated. Every American should take biden and oblama behind the wood shed.

  79. Facts Matter
    Facts Matter October 10, 2019

    'Russian Rudy' or 'Rudy Colludie'? don't even know what to call him anymore.

  80. cocomo
    cocomo October 10, 2019

    so trump thought to hire a Mafia hitman via Guillianni ?

  81. cocomo
    cocomo October 10, 2019

    I believe Trump is attempting to regain control of Alaska for Russians

  82. Jeff Semenak
    Jeff Semenak October 10, 2019

    Sorry Ari, you sold out for filthy lucre. Every question you ask should be asked of your boss. propagandist usually hang. I await the judgement of your peers.

  83. Joseph Palau
    Joseph Palau October 10, 2019

    Christine Todd Whitman???? The EPA Chief who lied and claimed the air was safe at ground zero????? Are you F' ing serious MSNBC???? I'm not even a Trump fan and your using this POS liar to convince me she has issues with the President. How many first responders are dead and dying now because of the lies told by her????? If your using her to back up your claim that Trump did something wrong YOU JUST LOST ME!!!

  84. Charles Jarrett
    Charles Jarrett October 10, 2019

    Here's a new leader of Ukraine the country was happy to have him as their new leader and what do we do we try to take this man to 2016 he was not president then you're asking him to clean up some mess somebody else cost instead of helping him protect this country and look forward Trump Trump is trying to corrupt this guy have him make up something on his rival Joe Biden he said he needs it in writing that's funny cuz he hides everything in writing on some different server he has everybody trying to lie for him but what's in the dark is going to come to the light he said he's leading in the polls is he talking about the ones that Stormy Daniels job

  85. T
    T October 10, 2019

    Rude Ghoulany is Donald tDump’s bulldog who is willing to do anything to cover up Donald tDump’s crimes.

  86. earthstewardude
    earthstewardude October 10, 2019

    Trump is Hitler and Giuliani is Goebbels… they both should be put in front of a firing squad when found guilty of treason! The historians will not be kind to either of those two fools!

  87. earthstewardude
    earthstewardude October 10, 2019

    Rudy looks like two pieces of coal pushed into a lump of bread dough.

  88. Pascal Nazaire
    Pascal Nazaire October 10, 2019

    Donald trump = bankruptcy check out his history

  89. DrLeroyGreen
    DrLeroyGreen October 10, 2019

    The house and Senate R's are now being held hostage. The only way they'll vote against him is if they can coalesce into a body that will feel confident that he will be jailed. Why? If merely impeached, they know that even once out of office he would still be rich and powerful enough to make their careers and lives miserable.

  90. Sophie
    Sophie October 10, 2019

    No proof of wrongdoing…aka: WORLDWIDE DEFAMATION OF CHARACTER BY PRESIDENT TRUMP. SUE.SUE.SUE.SUE.

  91. Sophie
    Sophie October 10, 2019

    Dont forget Trump's ACOLYTES…😊SUE.SUE.SUE.SUE

  92. Sophie
    Sophie October 10, 2019

    TRUMP 👂 BIDEN BOASTING ABOUT BEING A CROOK….. LIES. WORLDWIDE LIES ABOUT OUR POSSIBLE NEXT PRESIDENT. How's that good for the COUNTRY & FUTURE POLICIES with other countries.

  93. tubewatch59
    tubewatch59 October 10, 2019

    I'm fascinated for how long the left are going to attempt to continue with their position, that any talk of how the deep state tried (and is still trying – with the full aid of the press establishment) to oust Trump is all a "conspiracy theory." Probably right up until people start getting sent to jail. Actually that will merely get their attention a little bit more. They'll never actually wake up. They're now incapable of sorting out the need to prioritize facts over the desired narrative = A fools paradise.

  94. Korpulian Santos
    Korpulian Santos October 10, 2019

    What does Giuliani have on Trump?

  95. Maureen Davis
    Maureen Davis October 10, 2019

    I never liked the old version of Lindsay Graham…You could look at him back then and see the snake inside, it's not like it's a shock that he did a 360 he always struck me as that kind of person. Giulliani was always shady too.

  96. Owen C
    Owen C October 10, 2019

    Wasn’t he always?

  97. Arturo Duarte
    Arturo Duarte October 10, 2019

    Using Trumps words: Giuliani is a total DISGRACE and must be indicted for TREASON

  98. robertm4777
    robertm4777 October 10, 2019

    Rudy : Former. San Francisco Mayor: Rudy Giuliani Knows What He’s Doing | MSNBC Jun 4, 2018
    11,234 views•
    00:55
    Giuliani is a talented guy and believe
    00:58
    me he's the best thing that chump has
    01:01
    got going for him
    01:02
    all those other people don't count Rudy
    01:05
    does count and believe me in my
    01:08
    knowledge and my acquaintanceship with
    01:09
    Rudy and my occasional visit with him
    01:13
    when I'm in New York or seeing him when
    01:15
    he comes to California I'm telling you
    01:17
    this guy doesn't need meds he knows what
    01:20
    he's doing

  99. DjCole100
    DjCole100 October 10, 2019

    And to the poor sad sap who trusted and actually liked Gudy Riulliani is not legally married to his wife.

  100. Alibaba Blackthorn
    Alibaba Blackthorn October 10, 2019

    Donald Trump know he’s going to lose the 2020 election he’s going to bring down America with him when he before he leaves office destroy the constitutional norms laws our allies and friends around the world this is Putin‘s (BOY) this is white privilege at its worse a fool in the White House.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *